Strobe manufacturers typically publish the guide numbers of their strobes in air, but we wanted to test them in controlled conditions to see how they stacked up against one another. We especially wanted to see how they would perform with diffusers, as this is how we always shoot with our strobes when photographing wide angle scenes. Strobe,Sea & Sea YS-250,YS-D1,Z-240,comparison

Underwater Strobe Testing

Testing Methodology

Strobe manufacturers typically publish the guide numbers of their strobes in air, but we wanted to test them in controlled conditions to see how they stacked up against one another. We especially wanted to see how they would perform with diffusers, as this is how we always shoot with our strobes when photographing wide angle scenes. We also wanted to see how the strobes would perform across an entire frame; the evenness of the light is just as important as the intensity when lighting a wide angle reef scene.



For these tests, we used the same Sekonic Flash Meter in a room with the lights off. All strobes were tested at full power, ISO 100, at a distance of one meter, the same standard at which manufacturers also test their strobes.We wanted to test all manufacturers in the same conditions, measuring the relative differences in brightness between strobes.



While manufacturers quote the guide number at center, we calculated Guide Numbers across what would be a typical wide angle frame; at center, 12 inches out, and 18 inches out.



Interpreting These Results

The important thing to look at is the relative difference between the strobes, not the numerical value of the guide numbers. The guide numbers on the graph are f stop numbers, which are a ratio between lens length and opening, and are not an absolute measure of light. Each "stop" is double the amount of light. F32 to F22 is 1 stop of light, as is F22 to F16, and F16 to F11, etc. down the side of the graph. As the guide numbers decrease, the lens allows more light in, and the strobe does not need to emit as much light. As the number increases the lens opening is smaller and therefore the strobe needs to be brighter. All of our testing was with the strobe at full power.



This latest round of testing was prompted by the introduction of the Sea & Sea YS-D1 strobe which had a guide number specified from the manufacturer at F32, the same rating as Sea & Sea YS-250. We were surprised by the results in how close the guide numbers were comparing the Sea & Sea YS-D1 and Sea & Sea YS-250. When shot with diffusers, these strobes are about 1/4 stop difference in brightness. Since most cameras exposure adjustments are in increments of 1/3 stop, you would most likely not adjust the exposure between these strobes.



Out of all the strobes tested, Ikelite came closest to their published guide numbers.



Without Diffusers



Guide Numbers (1 meter in Air) - © Backscatter Underwater Video & Photo











With Diffusers



Guide Numbers (1 meter in Air) - © Backscatter Underwater Video & Photo



Strobes Tested in This Article









Related Posts

Sony a9 Underwater Camera Review—Shooting Great White Sharks

With the high speed shooting of the Sony a9 mirrorless camera and just released Nauticam NA-A9 underwater housing, we decided the best underwater photography test was to take it to the island of Guada...

Read More

Nikon 8-15mm Circular Fisheye Lens Underwater Photography Review

The new Nikon 8-15mm fisheye zoom lens was released only days before our departure to the Digital Shootout. We were able to MacGyver a makeshift zoom gear with a few items around the shop that worked ...

Read More

Panasonic Lumix LX10 Underwater Camera Review

When the Panasonic LX10 was released, all the specs pointed in the direction of a perfect compact camera. Large sensor, 4K video, and a zoom lens that does not require any housing port changes for wid...

Read More

Sony a6500 Underwater Camera Review

The Sony a6300 is a 24MP APS-C sized mirrorless camera that also shoots 4K video at a bit rate of 100mbps. You can shoot it like a compact with the kit lens and add wet lenses for wide angle and macro...

Read More

Nauticam Red Weapon Underwater Housing Review

Just when camera manufacturers started catching up with the resolution of digital cinema cameras released by RED, they were once again left behind with the release of RED’s new 8K Helium sensor. Gran...

Read More

Best Underwater Cameras of 2017: Compacts & Mirrorless

Updated in July 2017! We reviewed dozens of options and picked the best cameras suited for underwater photography. Top rated cameras for our 2017 review include the GoPro HERO5, Olympus TG-5, Panasoni...

Read More