Here at Backscatter we are fortunate to have a large customer base of professional underwater filmmakers. This year our conversations have revolved around three cameras: Red Weapon/EPIC Dragon, Sony a7R Mark II, and the new Canon 1DX II. We’ve had the chance to spend time in the water with all of the above, and each has their benefits and drawbacks. Here’s how the 1Dx Mark II stacks up...Canon,1Dx,Mark,II,Underwater,Camera,Review

Canon 1Dx Mark II Underwater Camera Review

Editors Note: This article was updated August 18th, 2016. We continue to have test cameras in the field and will update this article as test results are compiled.







Backscatter is fortunate to have a large customer base of professional underwater filmmakers. This year our conversations on 4K cinema have revolved around three cameras: Red Weapon/EPIC Dragon, Sony a7R II, and the new Canon 1DX II. We've spent many hours underwater with each of these cameras and this article compiles our Canon 1DX II tests from four uniquely skilled underwater professionals.







Canon 1DX II underwater housing system configured for wide angle.

Nauticam NA-1DXII Underwater Housing, Nauticam 8.5 inch Dome Port, Keldan Video 8M Lights, Canon 1DX II Camera, Canon 8-15mm Fisheye Lens.




WHO IS THIS CAMERA FOR?

If you're both an underwater photographer and filmmaker, our test results confirm the Canon 1DX II is hands down the greatest camera we've tested to date. It's a no compromise professional photography camera capable of shooting both 20MP stills at 14fps and 4K 60p video in incredibly low light. While it doesn't offer the raw video and flexibility of a RED, it shoots broadcast quality 4K motion at a fraction of the size and cost and out performs favorites such as the Sony A7 series in low noise when tasked with the extreme requirements of underwater white balance.



Backscatter has been spent over 20 years finding the best underwater cameras and we've learned that a chart topping land camera is not always the best underwater camera. The new Canon 1DX II is a good example. While leading groups such as DxOMark give it a ranking of 21st place, we give the Canon 1DX II a clear first place position for underwater applications.









The high ISO and high bit rate of the Canon 1DX II combine to make smooth blue water transitions without banding or red channel noise even at extreme underwater white balance settings of 50,000K+. This video was shot with Canon 1DX II, Canon 8-15mm lens, and ISO settings from 320-6400. Select HD playback of 4K for full experience. Video by Backscatter staff Berkley White.




REAL WORLD UNDERWATER LOW LIGHT PERFORMANCE

ISO performance results can vary greatly between underwater and land environments. Underwater we are forced to use extreme white balance settings of 30,000K - 50,000K or swim around with 10,000 Lumen lights just to illuminate a subject 3 feet from the camera. These underwater requirements can turn land camera test results upside down.



Our previous tests showed the Canon 1Dc was a top performer with a maximum of ISO 1250 for images in blue water and a maximum of ISO 2500 when shooting in high contrast or artificial light. The new Canon 1DX II now opens up blue water scenes to ISO 2500 and high contrast shots such as caves or wrecks in ambient light up to ISO 6400 even at extreme white balance settings.



White balance is less of an issue for underwater photography as raw files are easily corrected in post. For this application we do agree that cameras such as the Sony A7 series and Nikon D810 offer better low light performace, but we found the Canon 1DX II's combination of great white balance capabilities, high bit rate video, and great ISO performance make it the best performing camera for photographer / videographer professionals.









This video was shot at 50 feet underwater with only a manual white balance and no artifical light. Canon remains king when it comes to nailing color underwater with a manual white balance. The live autofocus of the Canon 1DX II was able to stay focused on this grouper, even at lips to lens distances with thin depth of field. Shot with Canon 1DX II and Canon 8-15mm lens. Select HD playback of 4K for full experience. Video by Backscatter Pro Team member Erin Quigley.




THE SIMPLICITY OF UNDERWATER WHITE BALANCE - WITHOUT FILTERS OR LIGHTS

Most underwater videographers have preferred Canon cameras for a good reason. Red light is lost within the first 10 feet underwater and you're quickly left with nothing but the blues. To make whites appear white in ambient light, you'll need an extreme white balance setting of 30,000K - 50,000K or more. Currently only Canon DSLRs offer this extreme white balance range to produce brilliant underwater color in-camera. As our previous testing shows, Sony cameras such as the entire A7 series are unable to white balance below 10 feet without a red filter on the lens as it is limited to 9,900K. Required filter use makes shooting in mixed lighting difficult or logistically impossible underwater. Our latest tests with the new Nikon D500 revealed it to be the best Nikon to date, but it often takes 10 to 20 attempts to register an underwater white balance at depth. RED cameras can white balance without a filter, but even modified with a H2O ELPF can't match the rich blues that are so easily produced with Canon cameras.



When performed correctly underwater, a manual white balance with the Canon 1DX II will almost eliminate the need for color correction in post and not burden the underwater videographer with filter maintenance or the requirement to always keep subjects within 3 feet of even the brightest underwater lights. If you want to keep it simple underwater, nothing beats a camera that produces great underwater color with a manual white balance.









While Canon's new autofocus system stunned us in wide angle and on-land tracking tests, it's still not quite there for real world underwater macro without further experimentation. Stay tuned for our new tests. Video by Backscatter staff Rusty Sanoian.




AUTOFOCUS WITH UNDERWATER CINEMA? - ALMOST!

Canon’s new Dual Pixel Autofocus performed incredibly well on land and we were excited to put it to the test underwater. This new Movie Servo AF system includes Flexizone Mode which offers a manually positioned zone at any point on the screen while the new AF Tracking Mode allows the focus zone to follow a moving subject across the frame. Experienced underwater videographers know that autofocus has only spelled certain death with all large sensor cameras to date. Thus, we were stunned to discover that Flexizone AF Mode was not only fast but extremely accurate in underwater wide angle scenes. For example, Erin Quigley’s video of the grouper was shot in Movie Servo AF even at close focus and low depth of field. Rusty Sanoian's Monterey video includes a tuna crab clip where Movie Servo AF performs flawlessly as the camera pushes forward and almost touches the crab. The Flexizone AF option for Movie Servo AF was the most accurate and responsive system we’ve seen for underwater wide angle.



We hoped AF Tracking Mode would shine with the razor thin depth of field in underwater macro scenes. This mode worked surprisingly well on land, but was not a slam dunk underwater. First, underwater housings don’t yet offer the ability to use the touchscreen to select focus points and require the user to position the focus zone with the joystick and activate with the set button. Secondly, water motion and passing particles seemed to cause the focus to hunt enough that we preferred to set and lock focus for most macro subjects. While some of Rusty Sanoian's Monterey macro video used AF Tracking Mode, the majority was captured by locking focus before each shot. We are currently testing lowering the secondary menu options that Canon has cryptically named "When Active" and "AF Speed" to see if we can make AF Tracking a reliable function for underwater macro.



Experienced underwater videographers should also note that the Canon 1DX II default setting is for Movie Servo AF to be enabled and thus the camera will AF continuously even when not recording. We recommend modifying the custom controls menu to reprogram the Set or the front Function button to Pause Movie Servo AF and always monitor the LCD to verify AF is paused during low contrast pans. Further, it's important to note that Pause Movie Servo AF will sometimes turn off after the camera goes to sleep or is cycled on and off causing unwanted AF activation. Underwater camera operators might find it best to turn Movie Servo AF off when shooting a full dive in very low contrast conditions.









Videos shot at 60p then slowed down to 30p has the effect of adding more drama to the image. More importantly, underwater shooters can't always set up a tripod on a pristine reef and slow motion helps us eliminate camera shake for hand held sequences. Video by Backscatter Pro Team member Dustin Adamson.




WHY IS 4K 60fps AMAZING FOR UNDERWATER VIDEO? - STABILITY!

We've all fallen in love with slow motion videos and the hidden world that is exposed when we slow down real time. The Canon 1DX II would not be considered a slow motion camera on land, but 60fps and 120fps video is about all we need in the fluid underwater environment. On land it may be easy to mount a camera to a tripod for rock steady footage, but we can't always drop a tripod on a pristine reef. Slowing down reality helps us add stability to our shots. Maybe that clip of the mother humpback with her calf caught you unexpectedly and you had some camera shake? Slowing your 60fps video to 30fps will double your clip length and smooth out your camera wobbles. Maybe you were fighting your tripod when a tiny jaw fish was aerating his eggs? Playback your video at 30fps to get 2x the time on a great macro behavior shot with less camera shake. You'll pay a price on hard drives when shooting higher frame rates, but you'll double your chances to get the shot.











CONS OF LARGE FILE SIZES AND ISSUES WITH NEW CFAST CARDS:

The Canon 1DX II is outfitted with (1) CF and (1) CFast card slot. All 4K 60P recording longer than 10 seconds must be recorded to the new CFast card. At a blistering 6GB per minute, you’ll need to buy 256GB CFast cards to get roughly 40 minutes of recording time per dive. New comers to low compression 4K will also need to upgrade their portable and home hard disks in a major way. Hard drives are inexpensive these days, but CFast card are bleeding edge and still demand a premium price.



Canon recently issued a firmware update to fix issues with Sandisk CFast cards. Our test pilots didn't experience any of these Sandisk issues, but one had a catastrophic issue with a Lexar 256GB card that was unrecoverable. Currently Backscatter is only recommending Delkin 256GB CFast cards as they have been the only cards without reported issues. Stay tuned for more feedback from the field.



WHICH 4K CAMERA IS BEST UNDERWATER?









Canon 1DX II VS. SONY A7 SERIES CAMERAS

In an era where airline baggage fees have people compromising with smaller cameras, the mirrorless Sony a7R Mark II has been a crowd favorite for good reason. Its large sensor produces beautiful low noise 42MP stills, 4K 30p video, and a complete system is easily carried on a plane all at a great price. It performs best when shooting macro scenes where features such as focus peaking and super 35 mode really shine. The Sony a7R Mark II becomes difficult to use for underwater wide angle. The above-mentioned inability to white balance without a filter makes shooting with or without lights on the same dive almost impossible. Advanced photographers will miss an optical viewfinder when trying to compose wide-angle scenes at upward angles. In these situations the mirrorless screen overexposes and only provides a guess on classic underwater photo compositions. Filmmakers will greatly prefer the 800mbps data rate and 60fps of the Canon 1DX II over the Sony’s 100mbps and 30fps when scaling to larger projects. For most people the choice between these two cameras will be a mater of budget, physical size, and ability to overcome the limitations of the Sony a7R Mark II.











Canon 1DX II VS. RED EPIC DRAGON

If your project has the budget, the RED EPIC DRAGON remains the ultimate “fix it in post camera.” RED continues to offer the greatest dynamic range, bitrate, and lens selection. If your project has skilled editors and colorists, they’ll prefer the flexibility that raw video offers to correct shooting errors and ability to color match a project across a wide range of unpredictable natural light sequences. The H2O OLPF filter and Dragoncolor 2 color space have significantly helped RED reproduce underwater color, but we’d like to see more underwater performance in a system in this price range. While RED remains king of large budget projects, the Canon 1DX II will certainly be the top pick for streamlined underwater productions. Based on our tests, the Canon 1DX II offers better saturated blues and overall lower noise in the blue light (red light starved) underwater environment. Assuming the proper white balance and exposure is attained while in water, the 1Dx Mark II footage looks fantastic out of the camera and is ready to pass to the Director or Producer in the field eliminating the need for expert level grading. If your project is heavy underwater and you have a medium to small budget, the 1Dx Mark II is an easy win.







Canon 1DX II underwater housing configured for macro.

Nauticam NA-1DXII Underwater Housing, Nauticam Flat Port, Nauticam SMC Macro Lens, Dive & See 5 inch Monitor, Light & Motion Sola 2500 Lumen Video Lights, Xit 404 Tripod Plate, Xit 404 Tripod Leg, Canon 1DX II Camera, Canon 100mm IS Macro Lens.




PRICE COMPARISON OF TOP THREE KITS





Canon 1DX II



Canon 1DX II Camera Body

$5,999









Sony a7R II



Sony a7R Mk II Camera Body

$3,199









Red Weapon



Red Weapon Camera Body

$52,000











WE KNOW YOU HAVE QUESTIONS - GIVE US A CALL!

The team here at Backscatter is just like you. We want to spend the least on our personal gear, but still get the most future proof camera system available. Give our cinema experts a call. We're happy to walk you through all of the options and guide you towards the best camera for your goals and budget.









Related Posts

Arri Alexa Mini Underwater Camera & Nauticam Housing Review

We take a look at the Nauticam underwater housing for Arri Alexa Mini with Backscatter's own Resident Cinematographer Matt Ferraro. Check out some awesome sample footage from the Channel Islands!

Read More

Olympus TG-5 and PT-058 Underwater Housing First Look & Detail

Olympus was able to get us an early release of the new Tough TG-5 camera and PT-058 housing. While we haven’t had it in the water yet, we were able to get some topside comparisons with the previous mo...

Read More

Panasonic GH5 Underwater Camera & Housing Review

We tested the Panasonic GH5 in our home waters of Monterey, CA and traveled halfway across the globe to Anilao, Philippines. Our main goal was to see if it would perform a manual custom white balance ...

Read More

The Best Underwater Lenses for Compact Cameras

Compact cameras do not offer interchangeable lenses, so these recommendations are for externally mounted wet lenses. The native lens on your compact camera is going to be great for doing fish portrait...

Read More

AOI UMG-01 LCD Magnifier for Olympus Compact Camera Housings Review

This is the AOI UMG-01 LCD Screen Magnifier for Olympus Compact Housings. This is the best accessory we’ve seen yet for the Olympus TG-4 system because it cuts out annoying screen glare in bright wate...

Read More

Best GoPro Underwater Filter and Macro Lens - Filter Solutions for GoPro 3, 3+, 4 & 5

The Flip Filter System by Backscatter provides you with the most comprehensive filter kit available. We've got you covered underwater with color correction, lens correction as well as topside len...

Read More